The Encryption Debate: a Way Forward

PRIVacySecured

1-john chen agm-001

Recent reports that messaging apps WhatsApp and Telegram have been employed by terrorists have brought the encryption debate to a head. The rhetoric has been acrimonious and polarizing, pitting privacy advocates who want strong protection from prying eyes against government officials frustrated by their inability to access criminals’ encrypted data.

For years, government officials have pleaded to the technology industry for help yet have been met with disdain. In fact, one of the world’s most powerful tech companies recently refused a lawful access request in an investigation of a known drug dealer because doing so would “substantially tarnish the brand” of the company. We are indeed in a dark place when companies put their reputations above the greater good. At BlackBerry, we understand, arguably more than any other large tech company, the importance of our privacy commitment to product success and brand value: privacy and security form the crux of everything we do. However, our privacy commitment does not extend to criminals.

BlackBerry is in a unique position to help bring the two sides of this debate together, to find common ground and a way forward. BlackBerry’s customers include not only millions of privacy-conscious consumers but also the banks, law firms, hospitals, and – yes, governments (including 16 of the G20) – that use our products and services to protect their highest value resources every single day. We stand as an existence proof that a proper balance can be struck.

iStock_000021161130_MediumWe reject the notion that tech companies should refuse reasonable, lawful access requests. Just as individual citizens bear responsibility to help thwart crime when they can safely do so, so do corporations have a responsibility to do what they can, within legal and ethical boundaries, to help law enforcement in its mission to protect us.

However, it is also true that corporations must reject attempts by federal agencies to overstep. BlackBerry has refused to place backdoors in its devices and software. We have never allowed government access to our servers and never will. We have made decisions to exit national markets when the jurisdictional authorities demand access that would abuse the privacy of law-abiding citizens.

We also reject any notion of banning or disabling encryption. The hacking epidemic over the past couple years shows that we need more, not fewer, security controls for our sensitive information. Frankly, it is surprising and unnerving that some national political leaders think that an encryption ban could even work on a technical basis. We, as a society, have decided that powerful computing devices that manage our identities, photographs, bank statements, and more are better to have than not. Users can install applications with encryption that precludes lawful access. If encryption services were banned, criminals would simply write their own encryption apps, resulting in a world where they have better encryption tools than the citizen populace, and our personal privacy would be the only casualty of this debate.

So the encryption ship has sailed; what, then, can service providers do to help strike the proper balance? The developers of Telegram demonstrated a simple example. Telegram offers two services: private point-to-point messaging and public group messaging (called channels). Telegram took decisive action to shut down criminal channels without affecting the point-to-point messaging service its customers depend upon for privacy. Make no mistake: service providers bear a dual responsibility to protect customer privacy zealously and to cooperate with lawful requests for investigative assistance.

It is practical to have public policy that supports law enforcement without impeding personal privacy. Ultimately, users have the right and responsibility to choose privacy with or without the potential for lawful oversight. We agree with the notion that there is no easy answer or formula to strike this balance. Hard things, we might say, are hard. That being said, it’s time both sides of this encryption debate accept that pointing fingers is counterproductive. Technology, over the course of human existence, can be both used and abused. We all have a right to privacy as well as public protection. We must balance these, and the world’s tech leaders must help consumers and governments alike make informed decisions.

About John Chen

John is a distinguished and proven leader in the technology industry. Prior to becoming Executive Chairman and CEO of BlackBerry in 2013, John was Chairman and CEO of Sybase Inc., which he re-invented, led to 55 consecutive quarters of profitability, and eventually sold for $5.8 billion. John has also been an executive at Siemens Nixdorf, Pyramid Technology, and Unisys. He is currently a board member at Wells Fargo and Company, Walt Disney Company, and various academic institutions and philanthropic enterprises.

Join the conversation

Show comments Hide comments
+ -
  • http://topbrandnews.com/the-encryption-debate-a-way-forward/ The Encryption Debate: a Way Forward - Top Brand News

    […] Source […]

  • http://worldsixty.com/technology/mobiles/blackberry/577643-john-chen-speaks-on-the-great-encryption-debate-and-where-blackberry-stands-on-it-all John Chen speaks on the great encryption debate and where BlackBerry stands on it all - WorldSixty.com

    […] BlackBerry CEO John Chen has decided to relay the company’s stance through a blog post titled ‘The Encryption Debate: a Way Forward’ through the Inside BlackBerry Blog. We’ve copied it below, so nothing gets taken out of […]

  • https://mcristinae.wordpress.com/2015/12/16/the-encryption-debate-a-way-forward/ The Encryption Debate: a Way Forward | MCE Blog

    […] Sorgente: The Encryption Debate: a Way Forward […]

  • http://techbook.co/2015/12/17/the-ceo-of-blackberry-has-attacked-apples-approach-to-user-privacy-bbry-aapl/ The CEO of BlackBerry has attacked Apple’s approach to user privacy (BBRY, AAPL) | TechBook

    […] CEO John Chen has taken Apple's approach to the privacy of users to task in a blog […]

  • http://immune.website/the-ceo-of-blackberry-has-attacked-apple-039-s-approach-to-user-privacy-bbry-aapl/ The CEO of BlackBerry has attacked Apple's approach to user privacy (BBRY, AAPL) | Immune Apps

    […] CEO John Chen has taken Apple’s approach to the privacy of users to task in a blog […]

  • http://www.lionmade.com/ign/2015/12/17/the-ceo-of-blackberry-has-attacked-apples-approach-to-user-privacy-bbry-aapl/ The CEO of BlackBerry has attacked Apple’s approach to user privacy (BBRY, AAPL) | Digital Wealth

    […] CEO John Chen has taken Apple's approach to the privacy of users to task in a blog […]

  • http://www.bns24.com/tech/2015/12/17/the-ceo-of-blackberry-has-attacked-apples-approach-to-user-privacy-bbry-aapl/ The CEO of BlackBerry has attacked Apple's approach to user privacy (BBRY, AAPL) - bns24.com

    […] CEO John Chen has taken Apple’s approach to the privacy of users to task in a blog […]

  • http://www.itproportal.com/2015/12/17/blackberry-ceo-criticises-apples-stance-on-privacy/ BlackBerry CEO criticises Apple's stance on privacy | ITProPortal.com

    […] CEO John Chen has used the company blog to lash out at Apple’s privacy practices, criticising its approach and saying that the […]

  • http://www.lankaphoneshq.com/the-ceo-of-blackberry-has-attacked-apples-approach-to-user-privacy/ The CEO of BlackBerry has attacked Apple’s approach to user privacy | Lanka Phones HQ

    […] CEO John Chen has taken Apple’s approach to the privacy of users to task in a blog […]

  • http://iosgears.com/blackberry-ceo-attacks-apples-stance-on-privacy-says-putting-reputation-above-the-greater-good/ Blackberry CEO attacks Apple’s stance on privacy, says ‘putting reputation above the greater good’ - iOS Gears

    […] CEO John Chen has written a blog post criticizing Apple’s strong stance on the privacy of customer data, suggesting that […]

  • http://www.fastfix123.com/2015/12/17/blackberry-ceo-attacks-apples-stance-on-privacy-says-putting-reputation-above-the-greater-good/ Blackberry CEO attacks Apple’s stance on privacy, says ‘putting reputation above the greater good’ FastFix123.com

    […] CEO John Chen has written a blog post criticizing Apple’s strong stance on the privacy of customer data, suggesting that […]

  • http://learnbonds.com/125704/blackberry-ltd-ceo-says-tim-cook-puts-apple-inc-above-greater-good/ BlackBerry Ltd CEO Says Tim Cook Puts Apple Inc. Above "Greater Good"

    […] can hold its head up high and stand as some sort of paragon in moral terms. CEO John Chen wrote a blog post lambasting Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL) for taking the wrong path to protecting user […]

  • http://appleact.com/blackberry-ceo-apples-privacy-stance-is-unethical/ BlackBerry CEO: Apple’s privacy stance is unethical | Apple Act

    […] Source: BlackBerry […]

  • http://androidfeed.net/il-ceo-di-blackberry-contro-apple-il-nostro-impegno-per-la-privacy-non-si-estende-ai-criminali/ Il CEO di BlackBerry contro Apple: il nostro impegno per la privacy non si estende ai criminali - Android Feed

    […] con un recente post sul blog di BlackBerry, il CEO della compagnia si è esposto contro la mela morsicata, sostenendo che il proprio […]

  • http://ncwtv.com/nn/the-ceo-of-blackberry-has-attacked-apples-approach-to-user-privacy-bbry-aapl-45827/ The CEO of BlackBerry has attacked Apple’s approach to user privacy (BBRY, AAPL)

    […] CEO John Chen has taken Apple’s approach to the privacy of users to task in a blog […]

  • http://fortune.com/2015/12/17/blackberry-encryption-apple/ BlackBerry CEO Calls Out Apple's Approach to Encryption - Fortune

    […] CEO John Chen entered the red-hot encryption debate on Thursday, writing a blog post explaining his company’s nuanced stance on whether governments or private companies should […]

  • http://crazyworlds.org/il-ceo-di-blackberry-contro-apple-il-nostro-impegno-per-la-privacy-non-si-estende-ai-criminali/ Il CEO di BlackBerry contro Apple: il nostro impegno per la privacy non si estende ai criminali – Crazyworlds

    […] con un recente post sul blog di BlackBerry, il CEO della compagnia si è esposto contro la mela morsicata, sostenendo che il proprio impegno […]

  • http://www.digitaltrends.com/mobile/blackberry-encryption-debate/ BlackBerry: Companies Should Comply With Lawful Requests | Digital Trends

    […] John Chen wrote a blog post to describe the current encryption debate, and what BlackBerry is doing to help the discussion move […]

  • http://rss.inb4sales.com/technology/arstechnica/blackberry-ceo-says-apple-has-gone-to-a-dark-place-with-pro-privacy-stance Blackberry CEO says Apple has gone to a “dark place” with pro-privacy stance – Inb4Sales.com

    […] the crux of everything we do. However, our privacy commitment does not extend to criminals," Chen wrote in a blog post titled "The encryption Debate: a Way […]

  • http://www.iphoneincanada.ca/news/blackberry-ceo-slams-apple-user-privacy/ BlackBerry CEO Slams Apple’s Approach to User Privacy | iPhone in Canada Blog - Canada's #1 iPhone Resource

    […] a new blog post titled “The Encryption Debate: a Way Forward”, BlackBerry CEO John Chen has slammed […]

  • http://www.sogotechnews.com/2015/12/17/blackberry-ceo-says-apple-has-gone-to-a-dark-place-with-pro-privacy-stance/ Blackberry CEO says Apple has gone to a “dark place” with pro-privacy stance - SOGO Tech News

    […] crux of everything we do. However, our privacy commitment does not extend to criminals,” Chen wrote in a blog post titled “The encryption Debate: a Way […]

  • http://mecwan.com/blackberrys-ceo-gives-you-a-great-reason-to-buy-an-iphone/ Blackberry's CEO Gives You a Great Reason to Buy an iPhone | SEO News | Technology News | Insurance News | Mecwan.com

    […] Cops and spies alike are up in arms lately over companies like Apple using uncrackable encryption on their devices. But Blackberry, whose clickity keyboards can still be heard in the halls of many government bureaucracy, doesn’t think criminals deserve privacy. […]

  • http://kemsat.com/engadget/blackberrys-ceo-gives-you-a-great-reason-to-buy-an-iphone/ Engadget Today » Blackberry's CEO Gives You a Great Reason to Buy an iPhone

    […] Cops and spies alike are up in arms lately over companies like Apple using uncrackable encryption on their devices. But Blackberry, whose clickity keyboards can still be heard in the halls of many government bureaucracy, doesn’t think criminals deserve privacy. […]

  • http://splitreads.website/2015/12/17/blackberrys-ceo-gives-you-a-great-reason-to-buy-an-iphone/ Blackberry’s CEO Gives You a Great Reason to Buy an iPhone | SplitReads

    […] Cops and spies alike are up in arms lately over companies like Apple using uncrackable encryption on their devices. But Blackberry, whose clickity keyboards can still be heard in the halls of many government bureaucracy, doesn’t think criminals deserve privacy. […]

  • http://www.jogleapp.co.uk/2015/12/17/blackberrys-ceo-gives-you-a-great-reason-to-buy-an-iphone/ Blackberry's CEO Gives You a Great Reason to Buy an iPhone | JogleApp

    […] Cops and spies alike are up in arms lately over companies like Apple using uncrackable encryption on their devices. But Blackberry, whose clickity keyboards can still be heard in the halls of many government bureaucracy, doesn’t think criminals deserve privacy. […]

blog comments powered by Disqus